IN 1975, CHARLIE RICH BURNED JOHN DENVER’S NAME ON THE CMA STAGE. IN 1989, THE CMA HANDED DENVER’S VOICE ITS ALBUM OF THE YEAR. The night Rich opened the Entertainer of the Year envelope, he pulled out a lighter and set the card alight before announcing “my friend, Mr. John Denver.” Denver accepted by satellite, gracious and completely unaware. Whether it was protest or too many gin and tonics, nobody has ever settled — Rich’s own daughter said he felt terrible that people took it as an insult. But to many fans, the fire came to stand for one question: did Denver’s gentle sound belong in country music at all? Denver’s answer came fourteen years later, when the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band invited him into the studio for Will the Circle Be Unbroken: Volume Two. Before the tape rolled, someone asked, “Is this practice?” Denver replied, “They’re all practice.” Then he sang “And So It Goes” exactly as himself — no edge, no attempt to sound tougher than he was. The single climbed to No. 14 on Billboard’s country chart. The album won three Grammys, and then the Country Music Association named it Album of the Year. The card burned in seconds. The voice is still playing.
The Night the Card Burned, and the Voice Came Back In country music, some moments last longer than the applause.…